Amber Noelle & Scott Gerhardt

Cinema IRL

Comedy EN ↓ 288 episodes

Cinema IRL drops you straight into the movie and asks the question, "what would YOU do?"In every episode, Amber and Scott (and the occasional guest) take movie plot points and run them through a real-life filter. What holds up, what falls apart, and what they'd actually do when things get messy. From impossible choices to wildly unrealistic storylines, they break it down, challenge each other, and uncover how these stories might play out in real life. Cinema IRL is smart, funny, and just the right amount of unhinged. (In case you're wondering about the dinosaurs on the movie posters, it was an...

Author

Amber Noelle & Scott Gerhardt

Category

Comedy

Podcast website

cinema-irl.donecast.com

Latest episode

Jul 10, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

E113 - Dog Man - What Would YOU Do? 24.02.2025

Amber and Scott saw Dog Man, yet both left the theater having seemingly seen two different movies. Listen and find out!

E112 - Companion - What Would YOU Do? 21.02.2025

AI has restrictions for a reason, and bypassing them is never going to be a good idea, as Amber and Scott discuss after watching Companion

E111 - Love Hurts - What Would YOU Do? 17.02.2025

Real estate is a killer industry, but not usually THAT killer. Amber and Scott discuss after watching Love Hurts.

E110 - Heart Eyes - What Would YOU Do? 14.02.2025

On this episode of Cinema IRL, the hosts dissect the horror-comedy Heart Eyes, a film where a fake kiss unfortunately gets two coworkers placed on a Valentine's Day killer's hit list. This leads to a hilarious roast of the characters' bafflingly poor choices, from their questionable escape tactics to complaining about being "ditched" mid-chase. The hosts even find themselves rooting for the killer...

E109 - Flight Risk - What Would YOU Do? 10.02.2025

On their podcast "Cinema IRL," the hosts tackle the thriller "Flight Risk," where an air marshal's simple prisoner transport becomes a nightmare when the pilot is revealed to be a henchman. This prompts a spirited debate on the proper sky-high protocol for when you have one too many bad guys on your plane. Between questioning the logistics of stabbing-related first aid and one host's deep suspicio...

E108 - Brave the Dark - What Would YOU Do? 07.02.2025

In a uniquely personal episode, the Cinema IRL podcast discusses "Brave the Dark," an intense film about a teacher helping a student with a deeply traumatic past. The movie review takes a sharp turn into reality when one of the hosts reveals he has a startlingly similar backstory of homelessness and teacher intervention. It’s a heartfelt look at the life-changing power of empathy that quickly beco...

E107 - Presence - What Would YOU Do? 05.02.2025

The Cinema IRL podcast tackles "Presence," a film billed as the year's scariest, but the hosts were more confused than terrified. The big supernatural mystery turns out to be a baffling combination of a regular "punk kid" villain and the brother's protective spirit from the future. The movie was so unscary that the hosts shared their own spooky encounters, which were less "The Conjuring" and more...

E106 - One Of Them Days - What Would YOU Do? 03.02.2025

What happens when the rent money gets spent on a questionable t-shirt business? The Cinema IRL podcast breaks down "One of Them Days," a film where best friends Drew and Alisa embark on a frantic, chaotic scramble to avoid eviction. Their day spirals into a series of hilariously poor decisions, including selling blood and accidentally stealing from a local gangster. Ultimately, their evicted belon...

E105 - Wolf Man - What Would YOU Do? 31.01.2025

Ever wonder if Hollywood gets werewolves right? The Cinema IRL podcast tackles the movie Wolfman with a very special guest expert: Morty, werewolf who's here to fact-check the film. Morty sets the record straight on everything from the agonizing pain of transformation to debunking the myth about silver bullets. Tune in to hear a real lycanthrope's take on his cinematic representation, including th...

E104 - Los Frikas - What Would YOU Do? 29.01.2025

Wanna trade food and shelter for AIDS? Yeah, probably not, but conditions matter as Amber and Scott discuss.

E103 - The Last Showgirl - What Would YOU Do? 27.01.2025

Nothing lasts forever, not even the classic Vegas Showgirl. How do you deal? Amber and Scott discuss after watching The Last Showgirl

E102 - A Complete Unknown - What Would YOU Do? 24.01.2025

I mean, it's a Bob Dylan bio pic. Amber and Scott discuss it.

E101 - The Damned - What Would YOU Do? 22.01.2025

If you see something, say something...or even better, do something. If you don't and not only don't help an entire ship from drowning, but actively participating in their deaths, expect hauntings and Amber and Scott dicuss The Damned

E100 - The Brutalist - What Would YOU Do? 20.01.2025

For our 100th episode Amber and Scott discuss one of the Oscar frontrunners, The Brutalist

E99 - Babygirl - What Would YOU Do? 17.01.2025

Who's down for a little high-powered humiliation? Amber and Scott...well, you'll find out after watching our episode on Babygirl

E98 - The Fire Inside - What Would YOU Do? 15.01.2025

Think you can win a gold medal and you're set? Yeah, as Amber and Scott discuss, it doesn't work like that.

E97 - Better Man - What Would YOU Do? 13.01.2025

Are you a Better Man than Robbie Williams? Amber and Scott discuss the monkey business.

E96 - The Room Next Door - What Would YOU Do? 10.01.2025

The quintessential "What would you do" movie, Amber and Scott discuss The Room Next Door

E95 - Mufasa - What Would YOU Do? 08.01.2025

Amber and Scott discuss the long-awaited Lion King prequel, Mufasa. Get into kitty for and discuss what would YOU do?

E94 - September 5th - What Would YOU Do? 06.01.2025

September 5th chronicles the media's coverage of the 1972 Munich Massacre. Amber and Scott discuss the importance of responsible journalism

E93 - Nightbitch - What Would YOU Do? 03.01.2025

I mean, it's a movie named Nightbitch. Of COURSE Amber and Scott were going to discuss it.

E92 - Interstellar - What Would YOU Do? 01.01.2025

For our Season 2 Premiere, Amber and Scott discuss Interstellar - if Earth dies, is there somewhere else we could go?

E91 - Y2K - What Would YOU Do? 30.12.2024

I took over and I'm writing a crappy intro for this podcast episode. It sucks. You shouldn't even listen to it. Humans just screw everything up.

E90 - Werewolves - What Would YOU Do? 27.12.2024

Amber is joined by special guest expert Morty to discuss Werewolves.

E89 - The Best Christmas Pageant Ever - What Would YOU Do? 25.12.2024

The Herdmans are a LOT. I mean a LOT. How much? Find out as Amber and Scott discuss The Best Christmas Pageant Ever.

Listen to the Cinema IRL podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.