Keith Nester

Catholic Feedback

Religion EN ↓ 106 episodes

A podcast exploring faith, life and culture, hosted by former protestant pastor and Catholic convert Keith Nester. In this Podcast, Keith responds to questions and comments from listeners and shares his unique perspective. Check it out!

Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: www.keithnester.com

Author

Keith Nester

Category

Religion

Podcast website

www.keithnester.com

Latest episode

Oct 29, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 10M+ downloads · 4.7+ rating iOS soon

Episodes

Episode 134 - Answering Tough Questions from Protestants w/Joe Heschmeyer 26.09.2025

Catholic Answers Apologist Joe Heschmeyer joins Keith to discuss the state of Catholic Apologetics, what he thinks about answering the same arguments over and over and much more! Joe's YouTube:      / @shamelesspopery   Join Keith on a pilgrimage to France!  https://selectinternationaltours.com/... For more info about Keith, visit:  https://down2earthministry.org/' Socials: Instagram:     / keithn...

Episode 133 - Evangelical Missionary is Fired for Becoming Catholic. Matt Selby's Conversion 20.09.2025

Matt Selby is the Director of Adult and Marriage Formation for the Archdiocese of Dubuque. In this episode, Matt shares his incredible journey to the Catholic faith (including how he was fired from being a missionary). Matt's website: https://mattlselby.com/   Join Keith on a pilgrimage to France! https://selectinternationaltours.com/product/saints-of-france-with-fr-aaron-junge-and-keith-nester/ F...

Episode 132 - Joelle Maryn's Illumination of Conscience 08.09.2025

Joelle Maryn is an award-winning actress, international TV host, and one of America's top 100 keynote speakers. Joelle has modeled for many national brands, was on a billboard in Times Square, and graced the covers of numerous books and publications. Several years ago, Joelle had a miraculous conversion experience and now shares her message of God's healing love that has inspired millions around t...

Episode 131 - He Became Catholic and Gave it All Away- David Abel 02.09.2025

David Abel has an incredible story of freedom, healing, conversion, and redemption. This man has changed the lives of countless individuals through his generous support of numerous ministries and his leadership. David is the founder and president of Stewardship: A Mission of Faith- a united family of ministries called to replace the lies of society with the Truth and the beauty of our faith. In th...

Episode 130 - Why this 20-Year-Old Left Protestantism to Become Catholic 20.08.2025

Zoomer YouTuber Evan Raugust sits down with Keith to share his journey to Catholicism. Follow Evan here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCmtg7MFzYouumRMjcO_efPQ   Join Keith on a pilgrimage to France! https://selectinternationaltours.com/...   For more info about Keith, visit: https://down2earthministry.org Socials: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/keithnestercatholic/ X: https://x.com/KeithN...

Episode 129 - Mother Natalia's AMAZING Journey 06.08.2025

Mother Natalia is an Eastern Rite Catholic Nun with the Christ the Bridegroom Monastery in NE Ohio. https://www.christthebridegroom.org/ "What God is Not" Podcast episode: https://youtu.be/oMrbe43odF4?si=BhKXsj2jBUnhnJ7w Join Keith on a pilgrimage to France! https://selectinternationaltours.com/product/saints-of-france-with-fr-aaron-junge-and-keith-nester/ For more info about Keith, visit: https:/...

Episode 128 - Fitness Legend Mike Pantile's Catholic Conversion 14.07.2025

Mike Pantile is a popular fitness influencer and entrepreneur who shares his amazing journey to the Catholic faith with Keith. The next day, Mike deadlifted 705lbs at the St. Michael Barbell club. It was epic! https://mikepantile.com/    / mikepantile   https://x.com/mikepantile    / @mikepantile   The Catholic Woodworker Rosary Crew Rosary is now available! Click here to order:  https://bit.ly/3W...

Episode 127 - Fr. Chris Podhajsky- The Priest Who Made Me Catholic. 01.07.2025

This episode is sponsored by The Augustine Institute. https://www.augustineinstitute.org/graduate-school/graduate-school Fr. Chris Podhajsky is the priest that Keith met with on his journey into the Catholic Church. He joins Keith for a fascinating conversation about the priesthood, marriage, the upcoming election of a new pope, and so much more. Salt and light book https://ignatius.com/salt-and-l...

Episode 126 - Curtis Mitch's Catholic Journey 17.06.2025

Curtis Mitch, M.A., is the principal annotator and Associate Editor of the Ignatius Study Bible series. Mitch joined the Augustine Institute in 2022 as a Bible Projects Managing Editor and concurrent Associate Professor of Sacred Scripture. Curtis joins Keith to discuss his personal faith journey and his work with the Ignatius Study Bible, which he worked on for twenty-one years! https://ignatius....

Episode 125 - Jim O'Day's Catholic Conversion 09.06.2025

Jim O'Day is the executive director of Integrity Restored. In this episode, he joins Keith to discuss his spiritual journey from the life of New York nightclubs to discovering the beauty of the Catholic faith. This incredible conversation covers Jim's journey as a husband and father and, eventually, his work in the battle against impurity. Jim's links:  https://integrityrestored.com/ https://www.t...

Episode 124 - The Religious Hippie (Amber Rose) 27.05.2025

Join us for a candid conversation about life, reversion, marriage, and what Gen. Z needs from the Catholic Church. Amber's website: https://the-religious-hippie.square.site/ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCX7C7Gh0oHVfvj5WKov_5HQ Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/the_religious_hippie X: https://x.com/HippieReligious To support the channel and Keith's ministry: Become a supporter and p...

Episode 123- JonMarc Grodi- Bringing Converts Home 06.05.2025

JonMarc Grodi joins Keith to discuss his faith journey and ministry to converts. The Coming Home Network https://chnetwork.org/ To support the channel and Keith's ministry: Become a supporter and part of Keith's Locals community https://keithnester.locals.com We also have Patreon: https://patreon.com/keithnester Keith's website: https://down2earthministry.org/

Episode 122- Kyle Whittington 21.04.2025

Kyle Whittington joins Keith to discuss his life and faith journey and why everyone wants to move to Steubenville, Ohio. Kyle's links:   @CatholicKyle  instagram.com/kylewhittingtonyt   https://discord.com/invite/IpsumAudite Catholic Creator Conference: https://catholiccreatorconference.com/  To support the channel and Keith's ministry: Become a supporter and part of Keith's Locals community https...

Episode 121- The Question about Hell That Made Jewel become Catholic 08.04.2025

Jewel Smith joins Keith to share her incredible story of conversion. Her story will change your life! To support the channel and Keith's ministry: Become a supporter and part of Keith's Locals community: https://keithnester.locals.com We also have Patreon: https://patreon.com/keithnester Keith's website: https://down2earthministry.org/

Episode 120- Mary Jo Burchard's Catholic Journey to Healing 24.03.2025

Dr. Mary Jo Burchard joins me for one of my all-time favorite conversations on this channel. Mary Jo is married to Kenny Burchard (former protestant pastor), who I recently interviewed. We laughed, we cried. It was awesome. Kenny's interview     • Kenny Burchard's Catholic Conversion   Mary Jo's Links:  https://a.co/d/53HMh6l https://a.co/d/ihyAI3Z   https://concordleader.com/ To support the chann...

Episode 119- Kenny Burchard's Catholic Conversion 05.03.2025

Former Protestant Pastor Kenny Burchard joins me on the show. Kenny has an amazing testimony of faith and his conversion to Catholicism. I know you will love this one! Kenny now works with The Coming Home Network, makes content for YouTube, and writes books. He is awesome! Please enjoy and share this video. Kenny's brand new book on Purgatory: https://amzn.to/3ZixfCs Kenny's YouTube channel: https...

Episode 118 Michael Girgenti: A Grammy Award Winner's Catholic Conversion 17.02.2025

Michael Girgenti is a two-time Grammy-winning producer/songwriter. He plays the role of Judas in the touring live production called "The Thorn." https://thethorn.com/ Michael is also a member of The Rosary Crew. Michael's instagram: instagram.com/michaelgirgenti/ To support the channel and Keith's ministry: Become a supporter and part of Keith's locals community https://keithnester.locals.com For...

Episode 117- Erica Seelman's Mixed-Marriage Catholic Conversion 20.01.2025

When a Catholic marries a non-Catholic, often there is a desire to convert each other. When Erica met her future husband, she told him there was no way she would convert. God had other plans. I hope you enjoy this interview, Keith To receive a free pocket Rosary Crew Rosary from the Catholic Woodworker,  become an ANNUAL supporter on Locals. Our Locals community has live streams, exclusive content...

Episode 116- The Catholic Woodworker- Jonathan Conrad 03.01.2025

Jonathan Conrad is the founder of The Catholic Woodworker. In this conversation, Jonathan shares his unlikely journey of turning a hobby into a successful and impactful business. Jonathan shares his struggles and dreams as well as how God has directed this venture and the impact it is making on the lives of so many people. Check out their site and the official Rosary of the Rosary Crew: https://bi...

Episode 115- Bree Solstad- From Tragedy to Catholic 09.12.2024

Bree Solstad is a former adult content producer who joins Keith to share her amazing story of redemption and conversion to Catholicism. To follow Bree on X: https://x.com/BreeSolstad or search for "Miss B Converted" Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/breesolstad/ Bree's Etsy shop for rosaries: https://avemariaeveryday.etsy.com/ Sponsored by Exodus 90: https://exodus90.com/keith To support the ch...

Episode 114 - Gabe Castillo Catholic YouTube Sensation 02.10.2024

Gabe Castillo @gabiafterhours digs deep into his life, conversion, and how to live the Catholic life. This interview hits hard! Gabe's channel: https://www.youtube.com/@UCukr20DPEICYc6nRLGvf9Bg Support Gabe on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/gabiafterhours Keith's locals: https://keithnester.locals.com Keith's Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/keithnester Attn men: Check out Exodus 90! https://exo...

Episode 113- Brandon Forchino's Catholic Conversion 05.09.2024

"Brandon Forschino was a successful business prodigy who fell in love with Jesus but was done with going to church. Then he walked into Mass, and his life was never the same. Hear his amazing journey to the faith. Brandon's YouTube channel: https://youtube.com/@brandonforschino?si=4fIhCxykeY2AG1JF Brandon's website: https://brandonforschino.com/ To help Keith bring in more guests for interviews, p...

Episode 112 - The Man Who Made Me Catholic with Devin Schadt 17.07.2024

"Devin Schadt is the man who first introduced Keith to Catholicism back in 1997. Their friendship has had lots of twists and turns (and so have their lives). In this candid interview, Keith and Devin delve into Devin's spirituality, how his upbringing has impacted his life, his relationship with his wife and children, and so much more, including that first night discussing Catholicism with a very...

Episode 111 - Dr. Travis Lacy- "I HAD to become Catholic" 08.07.2024

Dr. Travis Lacy, PhD. is a professor of theology. Formerly of Mt. Mercy University in Cedar Rapids, IA, and starting in the fall of 2024 at Providence College, Providence, RI. Dr. Lacy is a convert to the catholic faith from evangelicalism and shares his journey and insights with Keith. To support the channel and Keith's ministry, please consider joining one of our support communities: https://kei...

Episode 110 - The Amazing Catholic Conversion of John Edwards 16.04.2024

On Holy Thursday, 2016, John Edwards was arrested for purchasing cocaine, thrown into jail, and was facing losing everything. How did he get there, and more importantly, how did God deliver him from addiction? In this incredible in-person interview, John shares with Keith how God delivered him and set him on a new path. John is the executive director of Just a Guy in the Pew Ministries, which faci...

Listen to the Catholic Feedback podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.