Andy Koehn

Buy Like a Guy

Society EN ↓ 100 episodes

A podcast for men about how to buy cool things like bourbon, beers, watches and more, from experts who know their sh*t. It's always good to "know a guy." BLAG is collection of interviews and solo podcasts that cover the important things in life, like bourbon, beer, watches, and how to knock your girl's pants off with killer gifts. Third generation jewelry store owner and diamond expert, Andy Koehn and his guests will take you from confusion to confidence by opening the playbooks of experts who know their stuff. Think diamonds have nothing to do with bourbon or beers? Think again!

Author

Andy Koehn

Category

Society

Podcast website

www.buylikeaguy.com

Latest episode

Jan 22, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

Ep. 75 - Glitter & Grit: Pat Finn on the Sparkle of Necessity, Bonds of Friendship, and a Chris Farley Gem 25.04.2024

In this episode, Pat Finn and I continue our off-the-cuff exploration of the significance of fine jewelry, including a pretty sweet story about Pat's late friend, the legendary Chris Farley, and his love of gift-giving. We get a little sentimental, but it's cool, because that's one of the unexpected powers of jewelry:  it can connect us to our past and the people we love the most.  Jewelry is more...

Ep. 74 - The Male Experience of Buying Jewelry: Advice and Stories from Pat Finn 18.04.2024

Pat Finn is a well-known actor, comedian, and writer with over 25 years of experience in the entertainment industry. He's appeared in numerous TV shows and movies, including The Middle, Seinfeld, "It's Complicated," and the "I Am Chris Farley" documentary.  He has an almost endless list of professional accomplishments, and I wanted him on the show because he's also a husband, father, and regular g...

Ep. 73 - The Bourbon Brotherhood: A Beginner's Guide From "A Guy" Who Knows His Sh*t 11.04.2024

Bourbon continues to be a "go to" for guys who want to move away from cheap beer and fruity drinks, and I support it.  It's a crazy big world of choices that are mind boggling, even to seasoned bourbon hunters. My guest today is definitely a guy who can help us traverse the multi-leveled landscape of the bourbon world.  Derek works in the heart of Bourbon Country at one of the premier distilleries...

Ep. 72 - One for the Ladies: What NOT to Do When He's Picking Out His Wedding Ring 04.04.2024

This is an auspicious moment because in this episode, for the first time, I'm going to address "The Ladies." Specifically, I'm going to talk about what you, as a woman,  should NOT do when you and your fella go to look for his wedding ring. When it's time to pick out his wedding ring, he just might for your opinion. (Most likely he will!) And you should help him out by giving him one. (Or 2 or 3....

Ep. 71 - Ask Andy: What is the Custom Jewelry Design Process Like? 28.03.2024

Customer involvement in designing jewelry is a growing trend in the jewelry business. Independent jewelry stores offer a range of options, from changing metals and gemstones to adding unique touches. However, there's a crucial balance between personalization and potentially compromising the integrity of the original design when people who don't know what they're doing want to get their hands dirty...

Ep. 70 - Ask Andy: What is a "Push Present?" and Why It's a Legendary Gift 21.03.2024

A lot of guys have no idea what a "push present" is.  I have to confess that until there was a baby in my future, I never heard of it, nor did I know what it was.  (And I'm in "the business!") So what is a push present? Is it something you should consider when there's a baby on the way?   First, a push present is a gift that you present to your wife or girlfriend shortly after the baby is born, to...

Ep. 69 - Beyond the Carat: A New Direction for Buy Like a Guy 14.03.2024

"The times they are a changin'..."  I'm changing up the show and taking the podcast in a different direction!  Buy Like a Guy will be exploring topics beyond fine jewelry to include other areas of interest for men. But before I go, I'll talk about diamond reports, and reiterate once again the importance of seeking expert guidance when buying diamonds.  Grading reports are all well and good, but no...

Ep. 68 - Timing is Everything: Navigating Jewelry Buying Decisions, the Paradox of Choice, and the Importance of a Plan B 07.03.2024

In this episode of Buy Like a Guy, I revisit when the proverbial "right time" is to make your buying decisions, and the importance of having a Plan B. It's always best to buy important jewelry well before you're planning on giving it.  Why? Because it's the best way to avoid undue anxiety about whether it's going to be done on time for your big reveal.  Know what else happens?  You won't have that...

Ep. 67 - Diamonds are NOT A Lot of Money, and The Top 3 Things to Consider When You're Buying Jewelry 29.02.2024

In Part 2 of my conversation with Shane Decker we discuss the role of jewelry in celebrating life's events and he shares the most important factors to consider when buying diamond jewelry. The conversation covers various aspects of buying an engagement ring and creating a memorable proposal. Shane emphasizes the importance of choosing the right diamond shape and metal, considering the style of mou...

Ep. 66 - The Truth Behind Diamond Deals: Deciphering Beauty, Value, and Investment with Diamond Evangelist Shane Decker 22.02.2024

It seems like most, if not all, of the information and marketing messages coming out of the jewelry industry these days are geared toward women. It makes sense because oftentimes she is the driver when it comes to what sort of style she likes, and as men, we want to give her an engagement ring, or other fine jewelry that she will love.   However, a lot of guys can feel invisible in the process, be...

Ep. 65 - Ask Andy: The Marks of Time and Why Scratches and Dings In Your Rings are Not a Bad Thing 15.02.2024

In this episode I'm going to talk about something that resonates with both men and women: When you glance down at your brand new ring, and see those first few scratches and dings.  It can be disheartening, and you may even be surprised you even care.   Whether it's a minor scratch, a ding, or a chip, it happens to everyone.  It's kind of like those times when you discover a scratch on our car door...

Ep. 64 - You CAN Buy The Right Jewelry Without Sticking Your Head Up A Bulls A** 08.02.2024

If you're the kind of person that doesn't give a whole lotta' "you know what's" about fine jewelry or diamonds, or where the prices come from, I'm here to tell you, that's okay.  In fact, I think it's perfectly normal. If diamonds, gemstones, precious metals and fine jewelry don't interest you…don't learn about them. I believe this is true for pretty much all things.  If something doesn't interest...

Ep. 63 - What's The Hardest Year of Marriage, And Why Jewelry Is The Right Gift To Give For Your Anniversary? 01.02.2024

"So what's the hardest year of marriage?" You may be surprised to hear that I've been asked that question more than once. (Unless you're married. Then you know it's not an uncommon question, especially when you're talking to young men who are about to get married.) I actually used to ask that same question as a young lad working behind the jewelry counter. It was a nice ice breaker when someone wa...

Ep. 62 - Why Do We Wear Wedding Rings On The Ring Finger of Our Left Hand? 25.01.2024

As human beings we have an innate need to express ourselves to the rest of the world. Whether through our clothes, our time pieces, sharing our tastes in music, wearing our favorite team's merch…and of course, wearing a ring on the ring finger of our left hand, to tell others that, "Hey!  Hands off.  This girl or guy is spoken for." But how did this come to be an almost universal practice in Weste...

Ep. 61 - Why It Makes Sense To Give "Impractical" Jewelry She Won't Wear Everyday 18.01.2024

There are some fantastic pieces of jewelry that are beautiful and impactful, and they tend to cost a lot of money, and it's also the kind of jewelry that she won't wear "all the time." It begs the question, "Why would I spend a lot of money on something that she won't wear that often? It's not 'practical.'" That makes some sense I suppose, and it can seem like a valid reason not to buy that fancy...

Ep. 60 - Timing the Knot: Navigating the Timelines of An Engagement Ring Purchase 11.01.2024

In this episode I'm going to clue you in on something that I learned last week after talking with the girls here at the jewelry store. First time listeners, if you don't already know, I get a wealth of information about women from Lindsay, Susan, Kristyn, Katie, Morgan, Ali and my wife, Jenn. (Yes, I'm the only guy here.) A guy came in to meet with Lindsay for the second time, to decide which enga...

Ep. 59 - Ask Andy: Are Diamonds A Bad Investment? Part 2 04.01.2024

This the second half of a discussion I had with my friend and hero, Maarten de Witte, aka "The Diamond Wizard."  He's a living legend in the diamond cutting world, and he decided to tackle the oft repeated (and crazy cynical) idea that "diamonds are a bad investment." Are they?   Some people think there is no question that diamonds are a "bad" investment.  That the entire diamond industry was crea...

Ep. 58 - Ask Andy: Are Diamonds A Bad Investment? Part 1 28.12.2023

So I ran across a video where the guy in the video said that engagement rings were a scam and a rip-off and I just had to address it. But rather then answer it myself I brought in an expert jeweler and former director of the American Institute of Diamond Cutting to discuss this in an exclusive two-part interview. Take a listen and let me know your thoughts! If you want to talk with me personally y...

Ep. 57 - "You're Never Broke When You Own a Rolex" and What That Means to You 21.12.2023

I wore a Rolex as I recorded this episode. Not to impress anyone, but because I had a certain memory, and a revelation a bit earlier in the week that is wrapped up in the Rolex brand, so I thought I would share it with you in today's podcast. Certain possessions in our lives, especially the ones we've earned, or that were given to us from people we have a strong affection for or a bond with, have...

Ep. 56 - What to Do If She Sends You Ring Pics When You've Already Bought The Ring 14.12.2023

In this episode I'm going to address something that is rare, but it DOES happen, and if it happens to you,  it can bring on a not-so-slight feeling of dread.  And I don't think I'm being overly dramatic when I use that word. I'm talking about a simple text from your girlfriend or significant other, and it's a picture of a ring that she sends you, AFTER you've already ordered, or bought, the ring t...

Ep. 55 - How to Surprise Her with Jewelry You Know She'll Love So You Won't Feel Like an Idiot 07.12.2023

In this episode I'll address another great question from a listener.  He asked, "What are some best-sellers or guaranteed things I can get that fall in the range of a 'safe surprise gift'?    I'm asked this question in one form or another all the time, and it sounds something like this, "What sort of jewelry should I get if I want to surprise her, and KNOW that she's going to love it and I'm not g...

Ep. 54 - The Buy Like a Guy Top 10 List of Things You Should Know to Make Buying Jewelry Easy and Less Painful 30.11.2023

Someone asked me to put together a Top 10 list of the things a guy (or girl) should know to make buying jewelry less painful, and maybe even fun.  I personally believe buying jewelry should be fun. When I spend money I want it to feel good, and I'd guess you feel the same way. There is no pleasure in paying an electric bill or that speeding ticket, but there is certainly a feeling of excitement an...

Ep. 53 - Ask Andy: What's The One Thing You Should NOT Do When You're Buying Jewelry 23.11.2023

This episode was originally published in December, 2022 . Picking the "right" engagement ring or other fine jewelry can be unnerving as hell.  Questions start flooding your head..."what if she doesn't like it?"  "Is it the right color?" "Is it big enough?"  Those kinds of things.   A lot of guys fold at this point,  and say something like, "I think I'll bring her in and let her pick it out."  This...

Ep. 52 - How Soon Should You Plan The Ring Purchase Before The Proposal? 16.11.2023

Recently, a question was sent to me by a listener named Taylor.  He asked, "How far in advance should I plan the ring purchase before proposing?"  It's not the easiest of questions I've ever been asked since there are a lot of moving parts, but let me offer some guidelines that will help.   First things first, decide when you want to pop the question, and work back from there.  It's important to k...

Ep. 51 - 6 Factors That Explain Why a 1 Carat Diamond is the Best Bargain on Earth 09.11.2023

In this episode, I'm going to summarize a brilliant talk I heard "way back when," from a legend in our industry, Shane Decker. (I got his permission, and one day I'll have him on as a guest.) His profound love for diamonds and unwavering respect for the jewelry industry are truly remarkable. Shane's talk centered on the notion that diamonds, specifically 1-carat diamonds, are drastically undervalu...

Listen to the Buy Like a Guy podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.