Gary

A Rabbi And A Skeptic Walk Into A Podcast

Arts EN ↓ 56 episodes

Host Gary Rosenberg, a former atheist,  interviews Rabbi Alon Tolwin in a relaxed search for wisdom within Judaism.   Rabbi Alon Tolwin of Aish Detroit is one of the original class of six students who started Aish HaTorah with their teacher, Rabbi Noah Weinberg. Aish is the world’s largest Jewish adult education organization.   Reply  Forward GR

Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: www.buzzsprout.com

Author

Gary

Category

Arts

Podcast website

www.buzzsprout.com

Latest episode

Jun 21, 2025

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android almost 10M downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

2.2 Morality 04.05.2024

Morality, ethics, where do they come from? God? And what of moral relativism, William F. Buckley, right and wrong?  Stay tuned!

Season 2, Epi. 1. Music + Judaism= Ju-sic? 23.04.2024

Here is a Torah take on music and art from Rabbi Alon Tolwin.  The Torah instructs us that we should live with joy, and there is a  part that music plays as we kick off season two.

Bonus episode. SON OF A Rabbi and a Skeptic 23.03.2024

A very special treat today! Rabbi Simcha Tolwin joins me... to coax me to leap into Judaism 2.0--- kicking and screaming.  Me, not him .  Why does tragedy bring religion? Knowledge isn't the same as faith. Neil DeGrasse Tyson is name-checked. Why we go gray, and why that's a good thing. Thanks, Rabbi! Let's do this again.

27. The Rabbi wore loafers 15.03.2024

When does a ritual become a mitzvah?   We discuss the Dixie Cup effect-- featuring a story about Rabbi YomTov Glazer, then Rabbi Tolwin nails down a piece of consciousness . Danny Kahneman and Amos Tverski are name-checked, along with cartoonist Dave Berg from Mad Magazine  on how to honor your father and mother.... and more!  This may be the end of season one. Time will tell. Thanks for listening...

Episode 26. Miracle of Miracles 03.03.2024

I know, i know... it's pretty cheesy to name-check such a wonderful song from Fiddler. But, Hey, if I can't do that now, then when will I ever get such an opportunity?  Why, it's like a... whopper-tunity!  Mmmm, ...whopper.... An especially delightful chat with Rabbi Alon Tolwin of Aish Detroit about the three ages of miracles, and why they don't really impress anyone. I can&ap...

Episode 25. The Torah-- what to make of it? 25.02.2024

This week Rabbi Alon Tolwin helps your host see how the Torah should be considered. Is it a history book, a story book?  We discuss the bread of shame and free clothing. Can we take Torah literally?

24. Kaballah... Abra Cadabra! 10.02.2024

Ok, i had no idea the famous "magic words" are from hebrew!  Wait, what? As we scratch the surface of mysticism, Rabbi Alon Tolwin tells us that "while science can tell us how things work, Kaballah tells us why ."  Whoa-a-a-a. Mind blown.       A few minutes hence came this little atom bomb: "Everything we do lasts forever... leaves an indelible impact on the world we&apos...

23.Therapy for the host? 03.02.2024

This time it's personal. We take a break from the  high-flying  philosophy stuff to look at my relation to  Judaism.  I ask Rabbi Tolwin to discuss my effort to be a better person. Fer instance, why do I sometimes feel like I need to bonk myself on the head with a rubber mallet? 

22. Shiva: The best party of the year? 28.01.2024

The Jewish method of mourning, either orthodox or other than orthodox. Also in this episode, when the soul freaks out (so to speak), what does that mean? Rabbi Alon Tolwin of Aish Detroit sets me straight on a few things. Thanks for listening. If you are getting something out of this live, barely edited convo, please share it with a friend! Questions for the rabbi? Send them to rabbi2skeptic@gmail...

Sin.SIN.Sin. I see you, sinnahs! I hope you're proud of yourself. 18.01.2024

Episode 21. Sin-talk... morphs into a discussion of parenting, then the rabbinic rules about the charging of interest. Thanks for listening, and I played the theme music longer than usual this week, cause... I felt like it. What, is that a sin? Them music excerpted from my song "Under My Skin" performed by A Herring And A Half, formerly known as A Volley of Salvoes (hat tip to the great...

20. Praying for a parking spot 13.01.2024

Fish, Springsteen,  gratitude, dixie cups, the limits of metaphor, breathing, mercy, and "constant amazement."  Enjoy.

19. Why a Rabbi anyway? 04.01.2024

Pod gets a little bit personal this week, boys and girls. What kind of path leads to becoming a Rabbi with Aish HaTorah? Whatever you do, "Keep off the Grass!"

18. Proof? 04.01.2024

What if someone could prove to you there is a God? Would you change your mind? What does proof mean anyway?

17. Eeee-vill! 22.12.2023

Cue the scary music. Rabbi Tolwin and I discuss the nature of evil and how we might learn to think of it in a Torah-centric light. The pod's new email is rabbi2skeptic@gmail.com.  Please get in touch with questions or subjects with which we can tango. Let's start a dialogue.  Thanks for listening. Please share with friends if you get a kick out of it.

16. Education is Ethics, sometimes pronounced "Ettix" by youts 16.12.2023

Somehow this discussion of education sailed from business and retail ethical behavior and fairness to phishing and gullibility. Good clean fun!

15. Tikkun Olam-- "Repair the World" 09.12.2023

Rabbi Tolwin goes deep this week. This discussion really ranges, from slavery to Jimmy Carter to stolen candy bars. 

Episode 13. Science and Judaism 12.11.2023

This week, Rabbi Tolwin and I discuss the relationship of the Torah to science.  We touch on the writings of Gerald Schroeder such as his brilliant and helpful books The Science of God and Genesis and The Big Bang. There's your homework assignment for the week. And it will be on the test! 

A view from Israel 29.10.2023

Special guest Patrick Amar joins Rabbi Tolwin and me to discuss the war and related issues. Patrick, an Israeli citizen born in Canada, has been living in Israel with his family since 2005, working as a tour guide. 

Episode 12, season one. Doubt. 15.10.2023

Goethe said, "To have doubt is uncomfortable, but to be certain is ridiculous." I once met a rabbinic student in Jerusalem, 19 years old. He had never -- in his life!- met anyone with any doubt about God or the Torah or nuthin! Blew each others' minds. Enjoy.

Special war episode 11.10.2023

The horrendous events of the past few days are our topic today,  with an emphasis on some on "how we got here."   So much unknowable right now. So much sadness and carnage. Thanks for listening.

Episode 11. Zionism 08.10.2023

Let's learn about Zionism, shall we?

Season 1, Episode 10. Intermarriage 07.10.2023

Two things.  A. This is a topic with which I am intimately familiar, and  2. Why did this topic make the Rabbi nervous?

season 1, Episode 9. How does Judaism relate to the other religions? 30.09.2023

Talking about other religions can be fraught. Can be dicey. Can be spiky. Even  prickly sometimes. Stop me before I google a thesaurus. 

Season 1, Episode 8. Women and Judaism. 23.09.2023

Judaism's treatment of women in general goes under scrutiny from our skeptical host.  Side note--The host loved the Barbie movie, BTW, recommends it heartily, and was quoted as saying it was "the most important film in 30 years" and "girls (and the the women they become) will quote this movie the rest of their lives."

Season 1, episode 7. Gossip 16.09.2023

Isn't gossiping just harmless little fun sharing of juicy tidbits?   "Not so fast!" says Judaism. This is no small matter. Some tall ethical fences to climb here.

Listen to the A Rabbi And A Skeptic Walk Into A Podcast podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.