A Couple of Sassholes

🎙️ THROWBACK EPISODE — PRE-VIDEO ERA CHAOS We’re taking a few weeks off, but don’t worry — we didn’t leave you hanging. While we recharge, here’s a throwback to one of our earlier, audio-only, pre-video episodes that still absolutely delivers. In this classic Sassholes episode, greed takes center stage as we unpack just how far some people will go for a payday . Brooklyn breaks down the disturbing...

Christmas Day release… zero Christmas vibes in the story (besides the girls' holiday attire). 🎄 Because sometimes the best gift is a jaw-dropping true crime story you’ve never heard before. In this episode, Heather tells Brooklyn the absolutely unhinged story of Sheila LaBarre — a woman who presented herself as a fragile, misunderstood victim… while chaos, manipulation, and suspicious circumstanc...

This week, Brooklyn tells Heather the disturbing and heartbreaking story of Toni Henthorn — a woman whose life ended during a hike in Rocky Mountain National Park while celebrating her wedding anniversary. What was first described as a tragic accident quickly became something investigators couldn’t ignore. As details emerged, attention began to shift toward Harold Henthorn, Toni’s husband — a man...

This week Heather walks Brooklyn through the unbelievable and deeply tragic story of Dan and Nancy Brophy — a beloved chef and instructor at the Oregon Culinary Institute, and his wife Nancy, a romance novelist whose writing suddenly hit a little too close to home. We focus on who Dan was to his students, his community, and the people who adored him, while unraveling the strange, twisty investigat...

This week, Brooklyn tells Heather the heartbreaking and deeply unsettling story of Amber Creek. 💔 What began as a relationship that seemed ordinary slowly revealed red flags, manipulation, and control that would ultimately change lives forever. This case is a powerful reminder of how quickly things can turn — and how important it is to trust your instincts, listen to your gut, and protect yoursel...

This week on A Couple of Sassholes , we’re bringing you a Thanksgiving story you won’t find in your family dinner small talk. Heather dives into the heartbreaking and truly shocking holiday weekend for Joel Guy Sr. and Lisa Guy — a couple whose warm-welcome celebration turned into something chilling. We shine a spotlight on their lives, the unexpected turns, and the moment it became clear someone...

This week, Brooklyn brings Heather a true crime story steeped in Thanksgiving tension. Over turkey and stuffing, she unpacks the haunting case of Seth Privacky , a Michigan teenager whose family holiday spiraled into tragedy. What begins as a festive family gathering morphs into a weekend full of secrets, warning signs, and irreversible decisions. We dive into Seth’s background, the red flags his...

🔥 Sassy Replay: Episode #113 — Stinky Pinky 🔥 You already know Heather’s got a thing for cult stories — and this one takes it to a whole new level. In this Sassy Replay of Episode #113, originally released on September 12th, 2024 , Heather tells Brooklyn the wild, twisted tale of Sara Aldrete and Adolfo Constanzo — the deadly duo who mixed drug trafficking, dark rituals, and pure chaos in one of...

In this episode of A Couple of Sassholes, Heather tells Brooklyn the jaw-dropping story of Chante Mallard — a woman whose selfish, shocking actions cost Gregory Biggs his life… and whose desperate lies afterward made everything even worse. After hitting him with her car, she made a choice that would horrify an entire community — and it only spiraled from there. Buckle up, because this one isn’t ju...

When Brooklyn takes the reins, you know things are about to get spooky. This week, we’re heading to Greenbrier County, West Virginia — home to one of the most chilling and strangely historic ghost stories in America. A young bride dies mysteriously, a grieving mother insists her daughter’s spirit came back to tell the truth… and somehow, that ghost ends up testifying in court. Heather’s clutching...

Just when Heather thought she’d unpacked everything about ole Rusty last week… she realized Alice Crimmins was only getting started. 😏 In Part II, Heather and Brooklyn dig even deeper into the twists, trials, and tabloid chaos that turned this Queens mother into one of the most infamous women of the 1960s. Between the scandals, the secrets, and the courtroom circus — this case proves that sometim...

Heather thought she knew what she was getting into when she started digging into the story of Alice Crimmins… but ole Rusty had other plans. 👀 What started as a simple neighborhood tragedy spiraled into one of New York’s most scandalous, seductive, and controversial cases of the 1960s. This story was so wild, so layered, and so full of twists that Heather had to split it into two parts — without...

When a quiet Connecticut neighborhood is shaken by a brutal act of violence, detectives uncover a twisted tale of betrayal, obsession, and revenge. In this episode, Brooklyn takes Heather through the shocking story of relatives Joe Vulevic and Marash Gojcaj out of Danbury, Connecticut — a case that left investigators piecing together afamily bond gone fatally wrong and a community forever changed....

🎙️ This week we’re throwing it way back to March 2023 with a Sassy Replay starring radio royalty Chad Benefield — yes, that wonderful human from 92.5 WBKR’s morning show — is an honorary Sasshole. 💁‍♀️✨ Chad joins us to revisit a haunting true crime story that still echoes through the Midwest: the 1981 disappearance of 11-year-old Kathy Kohm in Santa Claus, Indiana. What began as a small-town tr...

Step back into the Great Depression with us as we stumble into the world of speakeasys, shady insurance scams, and one Irishman who just wouldn’t die easy—Michael “Iron Mike” Malloy. 🍻 This wild tale mixes true crime, dark comedy, and a splash of rotgut whiskey. New episodes every Thursday—don’t forget to rate, review, and subscribe so you never miss the chaos! ✨ Episode Sponsor: Natasha Conkrig...

🚨 Sassy Replay Time! We’re bringing back one of our most jaw-dropping true crime cult episodes — the Sarah Lawrence Sex Cult . Heather breaks down how manipulative con artist Larry Ray invaded a college dorm, brainwashed bright young students, and turned their lives upside down for nearly a decade. If you love true crime podcasts about cults, manipulation, and real-life nightmares, this replay is...

Brooklyn dives into the chilling story of Richard Speck—aka Dick Speck—a man whose crimes terrorized Chicago and left eight student nurses dead. From the one brave survivor to the shocking details that made him infamous, this episode is dark, disturbing, and impossible to forget. 🎧 Listen, laugh, gasp, and get a little sassy with us every week. New episodes drop every Thursday —don’t miss out! 💌...

When Mark Gerardo hit a midlife crisis, his pants—and his life—went completely sideways. Add in his wife, Jennair Gerardo , and his new love interest, Meredith Chapman , and you’ve got a love triangle that spiraled into chaos. Heather walks us through the shocking choices, the text messages that revealed way too much, and the heartbreaking fallout, while Brooklyn keeps the sass flowing. Who was th...

Brooklyn is back leading the sassy charge this week with another wild dive into true crime—this time, the chilling case of Kathy Bonney . Secrets, lies, and shocking family drama make this a case you don’t want to miss. As always, we bring our trademark sass, humor, and a whole lot of heart to shine a light on the victim’s story. ✨ Episode Sponsor: Natasha Conkright with Conkright Agencies! ✨ Na...

Heather tells the dramatic tale of Jean Harris—the elegant headmistress whose life became front-page news after her romance with Dr. Herman Tarnower, the famed Scarsdale Diet doctor, took a shocking turn. From her early years to her powerful career, the media frenzy, her trial, prison activism, and legacy, this story has it all. If you love true crime, courtroom drama, and stories that shaped Amer...

It was supposed to be the perfect summer getaway for the Robison family. A quiet cabin. A sparkling lake. Time to relax… until the peaceful picture shattered into a decades-long mystery that still keeps people guessing. 🌲🛶 This week, Brooklyn unpacks the strange twists, puzzling clues, and the lingering shadows over a case that left an entire community shaken. It’s one part history, one part who...

You think you know someone... until you don’t. In this jaw-dropping two-part special, the Sassholes (virtually) sit down with Kelly Sutliff —licensed psychotherapist, domestic violence survivor, and breakout voice from the 2025 ID Channel's premiere episode of the true crime docuseries Toxic on HBO Max. In Part II , Kelly opens up about the legal battle, the media spotlight, and how she found...

You think you know someone... until you don’t. In this jaw-dropping two-part special, the Sassholes (virtually) sit down with Kelly Sutliff , licensed psychotherapist, domestic violence survivor, and breakout voice from the 2025 ID Channel's premiere episode of the true crime docuseries Toxic on HBO Max. In Part I, Kelly shares her raw, real, and deeply personal story of survival and strength—with...

Just a few hours from our sassy hometown of Owensboro, KY, in a town called Columbia, KY, a loving family was torn apart by greed, adultery, and a twisted love triangle. 💔 In this week’s episode, Heather tells the chilling story of Dr. Joseph Wellnitz, his wife Beth, and their son Dennis — three kind-hearted animal lovers whose lives ended far too soon. As the investigation unfolds, a tangled web...

This week on A Couple of Sassholes , Brooklyn breaks down the absolutely unhinged story of Alex Ewing —aka the Hammer K*ller. And yes, she might have said “Ear Wig” a few times… but like a true menace, Heather ran with it like her life depended on it. 🪰💅 We’re talkin’ brutal crimes, DNA drama, and a prison escape that sounds more like a Looney Tunes episode than real life. Also: WHY do baby hand...