2 Girls Who Scare Easily

If you listed to Part 1 of our Toni Henthorn story, you know we were feeling pretty suspicious of her husband, Harold. This episode discusses how he behaved after the "accident" as well as what law enforcement thought about the whole thing. Send us your thoughts at 2girlswhoscareeasily@gmail.com, and follow us on instagram @2girlswhoscareeasily Theme song is by Chris Nugen, and features Glenn Ross...

Back in September of 2012, Toni (Bertolet) Henthorn was on a hike with her husband for their anniversary when she tragically fell to her death, but was it an accident? Or was she pushed?   Send us your thoughts at 2girlswhoscareeasily@gmail.com, and follow us on instagram @2girlswhoscareeasily Theme song is by Chris Nugen, and features Glenn Ross Sources: Caleb Hannan, 2017. The Accident...

The night of July 31, 1976 the Big Thompson Canyon was hit with a massive flood that no one saw coming. Katie takes us through the combination of natural and man-made factors that contributed to this massive wall of water taking out homes and costing lives. If you've got a natural disaster story, share it  (or other spooky Colorado stories) with us at 2girlswhoscareeasily@gmail.com , and foll...

In early September of 1967, a rancher in the San Luis Valley made a gruesome and mysterious discovery - the mutilated body of one of his horses. But what could have done it? Aliens? Radioactive ants? Andy helps unravel the mystery in this week's episode about Snippy the Horse! Share your alien encounters (or other spooky Colorado stories) with us at 2girlswhoscareeasily@gmail.com, and follow us on...

Cripple Creek, Colorado is a town well known for being haunted. And given it's history, it's not hard to see why! Katie does a deep dive into a hospital-turned-hotel and all it's ghostly inhabitants in this weeks episode! Share your ghost stories (or other spooky Colorado stories) with us at 2girlswhoscareeasily@gmail.com , and follow us on instagram @2girlswhoscareeasily https://hotelstnicholas.c...

This week, Andy share's the mysterious story of a murder in a locked house, followed by the haunting of the poor widow! Share your ghost stories (or other spooky Colorado stories) with us at 2girlswhoscareeasily@gmail.com, and follow us on instagram @2girlswhoscareeasily https://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn96077289/1942-08-01/ed-1/seq-1/#date1=1789&index=0&rows=20&words=Coneys+Ed...

Red Rocks is a world famous concert venue in Morrison, Colorado and a gorgeous place to hike. But rumor has it that it's haunted by a hatchet-wielding former resident! Katie shares all the spooky details (plus some bonus true crime) in this episode! Share your spooky Red Rocks experiences with us at 2girlswhoscareeasily@gmail.com, and follow us on instagram @2girlswhoscareeasily https://www.uncove...

Riverdale road runs 11 miles between Thornton and Brighton Colorado, and legend has that it's one of the most haunted roads in America AND is home to the "Gates of Hell!" There are tales of a woman in white, ghost jogger, phantom Camaro, ghost children, and even flesh pedestrians! On top of all that, there's a whole slew of true crime that's taken place on this secluded road.  Sources: ...

Welcome to 2 Girls Who Scare Easily - a podcast about spooky, weird, and interesting things in and around Colorado! Join Andy and Katie weekly as they share stories and try to scare each other (spoiler - it's not hard). Get to know the ladies this week, including what lead to their interests in all things spooky!