The Murder Diaries

Original Air Date: 7/10/2024 Sandra Nestle was 32 years old when she was assaulted and murdered on a desolate Michigan back road. After 40 years behind bars, her killer may walk the streets again. Resources: ⁠https://themurderdiariespodcast.com/episodes/template-9webg-nwtpj-t96tc-b64ps-f7lrd-lwllk-s8gla-j69fp-t25s5-yybna-rtjlw-t4g9a-823ee-f98sp-45zm3-3h326-9f8ce-889n2-rhneb-wglbj-dn8ex-pnbt6-xcd7h...

The holidays have officially begun, and Paige and Natalie are sleighing straight into the season with the undisputed Queen of Christmas herself — Mariah Carey. In this week’s festive deep dive, the Unscripted duo unwraps everything: from her glittering rise to superstardom and iconic whistle notes to the untold stories behind her legendary holiday empire. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit me...

Down on her luck and far from home, Trish Hanyes was lured into a toxic living situation with a former childhood bully. And then she disappeared. When her remains were found in a nearby pond, all evidence pointed back to the husband and wife she lived with. If you or someone you know have information about Trish’s case, call the New Hampshire State Police at 603-223-4381. That’s 603-223-4381. You...

This week on Unscripted, Natalie and Paige spill the tea on the Jonas Brothers and digging into the rumors, brotherly relationship drama, and behind-the-scenes moments that kept fans obsessed. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

In March of 2018, 31-year-old Jennifer Myers was pronounced deceased by EMS at the home of a stranger, from what was later ruled a self-inflicted gunshot wound. Her family may never have the answers they so desperately want, but there’s multiple loose ends that show that the investigation into Jen’s death fell short. Will Jen’s case remain closed with a rushed ruling of suicide, or will detectives...

The week Paige and Natalie dive in to the drama surrounding the recent season of Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, and it's JUICY! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

By the age of 23, Selena Quintanilla-Pérez had earned the moniker “Queen of Tejano music.” She was a musical powerhouse and adept businesswoman, whose fashion and music contributions have influenced multiple generations. She worked tirelessly to build her dream life– a booming career, a tight-knit family, and a loving husband, when everything was cruelly ripped away from her by someone she thought...

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Heather Teague was just 23 years old when she was abducted from the banks of the Ohio River in Kentucky in August of 1995. Despite having a witness who saw the entire abduction, Heather remains missing. Though the Kentucky State Police have told Heather’s mother that her daughter’s abductor is dead, she believes there is much more to the case than investigators are willing to admit. If you have an...

This week on Unscripted, Natalie and Paige are zig-a-zig-ah-ing their way through the rise, reign, and rollercoaster of the Spice Girls. From their perfectly chaotic auditions to global domination (and those platform shoes), the girls break down how five wildly different personalities changed pop forever. Our Unscripted segment will be moving to its own RSS feed starting January 2026. Until then,...

Two longtime friends. Meeting for a heart-to-heart talk on a bench in a busy park outside Cleveland, Ohio. Ten minutes after arriving, their bodies were found. Shot to death in cold blood. In broad daylight. Six years later, the double homicides remain one of Northeast Ohio's most perplexing cold cases. No motive. No eyewitnesses. No suspects. Just two families shattered, left with far more questi...

This week on Unscripted, Natalie and Paige dive deep into the life and career of Selena Gomez. They’re unpacking everything from her early TV days to her on-again-off-again with Justin Bieber, plus how she traded her pop career for a billion dollar beauty brand. Expect nostalgia, a few strong opinions, and the kind of unfiltered commentary you only get from two people who’ve spent way too much tim...

A home invasion. A senseless murder. Both events happened in homes right next door to one another on the same morning and left a loving father shot to death in the living room of his home. Were these random acts of violence … or were the crimes related? Listen to Ice Cold Case: https://open.spotify.com/show/5KZGIllYsj8jrQ6itE2AfB?si=58c96501b5f94de1 Listen Ad Free And Get Access to Exclusive Journ...

This week on Unscripted, Natalie and Paige go song by song through Taylor Swift’s latest album, The Life of a Showgirl. From the sparkling opener to the devastating closer, they’re breaking down lyrics, Easter eggs, and those very specific “I swear she’s talking about him” moments. Expect theories, debates, and maybe one too many dramatic readings of her most unhinged lines. Our Unscripted segment...

We're diving into a story that's currently unfolding in real time. But this time we have a special guest to join us to do that. This case is out of Memphis and is raising serious questions about the criminal justice system, eyewitness reliability, and what happens when new evidence emerges decades later. Our guest today is investigative journalist Stephanie Tinsley, whose recent work with the Tenn...

Paige brings Natalie up to speed on all the Laguna Beach drama, from iconic love triangles to the moments that defined early 2000s reality TV. Our Unscripted segment will be moving to its own RSS feed starting January 2026. Until then, you can continue enjoying it right here on this feed. Be sure to follow and subscribe to the new feed so you don’t miss any of the great conversations coming your w...

In April of 2010, high school student Ali Lowitzer disappeared after getting off her school bus in her hometown of Spring, Texas. Her parents wonder if she was abducted and forced into the world of human trafficking, but the case has gone cold leaving Allie‘s loved ones with thousands of unanswered questions and no answers. Will Ali ever be found and will her family ever get the answers that they’...

Video Version: https://youtu.be/psAwMWo_4jA Natalie & Paige are joined by the one and only Gay Man with a Spray Tan for a deep dive into all things Kardashian-- with a K! From reality TV to business empires, and everything in between, we're unpacking the chaos, the glam, and the legacy. Our Unscripted segment will be moving to its own RSS feed starting January 2026. Until then, you can continue en...

As you listen to our interview with Katie Palmer’s husband, we want to share an important update. A Grayson County Grand Jury has indicted the driver, Cory Todd Foster, on a manslaughter charge in connection with Katie’s death in 2020. The district attorney’s office confirmed there is probable cause that Foster recklessly caused her death. This indictment marks a significant step forward in the pu...

Natalie & Paige deep dive into the life and career of Hilary Duff, from her Lizzie McGuire days to her pop music era and current TV success. They cover it all, including her early 2000s feud with Lindsay Lohan and some of her more problematic relationships. Our Unscripted segment will be moving to its own RSS feed starting January 2026. Until then, you can continue enjoying it right here on this f...

On a cold, stormy night in Dublin, Trevor Deely left his office after a Christmas party and disappeared without a trace. Caught on CCTV one moment and gone the next, his case remains one of Ireland’s most haunting unsolved mysteries. If you have any information about Trevor Deely, please contact Gardaí at Pearse Street station on 01 6669000 or information can also be given via the Garda Confidenti...

This week on Unscripted, Natalie and Paige dive into the Cult of American Apparel documentary, dissecting the rise and fall of the iconic brand and the controversy surrounding its founder. From provocative marketing to toxic workplace culture, they explore how a company that promised authenticity became a cautionary tale. Tune in for hot takes, thoughtful commentary, and a candid conversation you...

Just 14 years old. A shy girl. A cheerleader. A member of the school band. One warm summer night, she told her older brother she was walking to a friend’s house for a sleepover. She never showed up. A few months later, hunters found her body in a secluded wooded area of an Ohio state park, two hours away from her Pennsylvania home. It took nine years for authorities to identify her remains through...

This week, Natalie and Paige spotlight Ashlee Simpson. You know, the younger Simpson sister who stepped out of Jessica’s shadow with a side part, a punk attitude, and a reality show of her own. From her chart-topping debut to that infamous SNL moment, Ashlee’s rise was fast, messy, and unforgettable. The girls break down the highs, the headlines, and how Ashlee handled the kind of public flop that...

You read that right, AMANDA FREAKING KNOX. From 2007 to 2015, Amanda spent nearly four years in an Italian prison, and eight years on trial for a crime she didn't commit. Her name became a global headline, but she's so much more than the story the world thought it knew. She's an exoneree, journalist, public speaker, and author of two powerful books. The New York Times bestseller, Waiting to be Hea...