Amy Robach & T.J. Holmes Present

Actress/Director Elisabeth Röhm takes us inside two true crime stories where the threat wasn’t a stranger, it was a father. Larry Ray, newly out of prison, was allowed to move into his daughter’s college dorm and slowly take control of her friends. How his manipulation starts as “help,” how shame and exhaustion chip away at identity, and how smart young people can lose...

The judge in the au pair affair murder trial went against the prosecution and its star witness, sentencing Au pair Juliana Maghaleas to 10 years in prison. Maghaleas testified against her former boss and lover, Brendan Banfield, securing his conviction, thinking she was securing her freedom. The judge had other plans, and some harsh words for the 25-year-old, telling her she should spend the rest...

Some major developments have occurred overnight in the search for missing 84 year old Nancy Guthrie.  First, Fox News is reporting 3 people have been detained in connection with the case, while police have confirmed law enforcement activity at a nearby residence.  TMZ has revealed a third note from same author asking for more money and suggesting the crime is international.  All thi...

Police didn't commission it, but there's a just-released forensic artist's sketch of the possible suspect in the Nancy Guthrie disappearance. And it's coming from a renowned, even legendary sketch artist who Guinness dubbed the "Most Successful Forensics Artist" in the world. She based the sketch on the surveillance images released by authorities this week. Will it help or hinder the case?  S...

There were several late-breaking updates in the case of missing 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie.  The FBI has released a description of the suspect as well as doubled the reward for information.  But also today, TMZ has received a 2nd note from the person who claims to know who the real kidnapper is.  Harvey Levin described the note as "chilling." See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy i...

Actress and Director Elisabeth Röhm takes us inside the true story behind The Dating App Killer, the new movie based on the real-life case of the shopping cart murders. Elisabeth pulls back the curtain on the predator who hunted women through dating apps, and how one woman was captivated by a man so charming and soft-spoken, she didn’t realize she was face-to-face with a monster hiding...

Border Czar Tom Homan just announced that President Trump has agreed to end Operation Metro Surge in Minneapolis.  This surprising move comes after last week’s decision to remove 700 agents and after weeks of protests and outrage over the killings of protesters Renee Good and Alex Pretti. ” See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

A new note, new searches, and thousands of new tips.  It's now nearly two weeks since Nancy Guthrie was last seen, and authorities are now dealing with another note sent to a media outlet, but this note claims to be from someone who is NOT a kidnapper.  Rather, the person claimed to know who the real kidnapper is, but in order to reveal it, they want Bitcoin first.   See omnyst...

A LOT has happened in the past 24 hours in the case of missing 84 year old Nancy Guthrie.  Police arrested a man, held him for hours while searching his vehicle and home, before eventually releasing him in the early morning hours.  “Carlos” spoke to reporters about his arrest, saying he doesn’t even know who Savannah Guthrie is, or anything about a kidnapping because he...

A potentialy case-breaking development. The FBI today released several images and videos from the doorbell camera at Nancy Guthrie's home the night she disappeared. They show a man in a mask with gloves, and the images seem to put to rest any doubts about whether or not Guthrie was actually abducted. See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Two Republican congressman are demanding answers and consequences for Bad Bunny’s halftime performance they say was “pure smut” that forced American families to witness “explicit displays of gay sexual acts.” One Tennessee congressman has gone so far as to ask for a formal congressional inquiry into the NFL and NBC Universal for their prior knowledge and approval of e...

Another video with a very different tone.  Savannah Guthrie just put out another video speaking directly to the public, asking for help.  There was no reference to a kidnapper or a ransom note, as the Guthrie family continues to race against time to find their missing 84 year old mom, who police say was take against her will 9 days ago.  See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy infor...

Keith Zlomsowitch, Nicole Brown Simpson’s former boyfriend, recounts the days after her murder, when the danger didn’t feel over. From holding Nicole’s casket at her funeral to being warned to stay away from her condo after O.J. said he was “coming to finish what he started.” Keith lays out why he went to the police, why his testimony wasn’t used in the trial an...

The family of Nancy Guthrie released a new video via Instagram on Saturday in which they pleaded with kidnappers for the return of their mother.  But the tone and some of the language used in the video suggested that the siblings may have communicated with a third party, offering to pay,  so that they can have peace.  See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

It's been a full week since Savannah Guthrie's mom has been missing, and the latest update comes from President Trump himself, who told reporters on Air Force One that law enforcement is close to having some answers.  We've also learned that another ransom note has been sent to the local Tucson affiliate, the FBI has returned to search Nancy Guthrie's home and there may be a vehicle of intere...

Thursday was a day of developments in the case of Nancy Guthrie, yet police say they still don't have a suspect.  Guthrie's son made another on-camera plea for kidnappers to contact them.  But police haven't' confirmed the credibility of any ransom note. Meanwhile, police arrested a California man, who's accused of trying to take advantage of the Guthrie family.  See omnystudio.com/...

This isn’t the O.J. story you already know. Keith Zlomsowitch, Nicole Brown Simpson’s former boyfriend, takes us back to the months before the murders when he says stalking, intimidation, and fear were part of his daily life. Keith talks about dating Nicole, O.J. watching them have sex, the warning signs that went unheeded, and why these moments never made it into The People v. O.J. Si...

The children of Nancy Guthrie made an emotional, on-camera plea to the person(s) potentially holding their mother hostage.  Savannah Guthrie, flanked by her brother and sister, said they are "ready to talk" but said they first needed to know "without a doubt" that their mother was alive.  Amy and T. J. discuss the significance of the family's move -- which came at the end of the day of t...

Amy and T.J. discuss one of the most elaborate and unthinkable murder cases they’ve ever covered with criminal defense attorney extraordinaire Alison Treissl. 40-year-old former IRS agent Brandon Banfield was found guilty this week of killing his wife Christine and a stranger he lured to his home, Joe Ryan. While Amy and T.J. thought the defense raised some reasonable doubt with two experts...

As police continue to investigate the abduction of the 84 year old mother of Savannah Guthrie, the Sheriff’s department had to put out a statement today refuting an allegation made by journalist Ashleigh Banfield.  Banfield has claimed a “high level source” told her that Savannah’s brother-in-law may be the prime suspect in Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance.  As...

Another twist in the mysterious disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, mother of "Today" co-host Savannah Guthrie.  A local Arizona news station is reporting that is also received a ransom note, but decided to withhold it from the public at the request of police.  TMZ a different decision, and according to the sheriff, went public with the ransom note it received before contacting authorities,...

Another bizarre turn in the abduction of Savannah Guthrie’s mom.  TMZ has given police a ransom note they received from someone who claims to have Nancy Guthrie, demanding millions in cryptocurrency by a specific deadline, “or else.”  TMZ says the note has details about the crime scene that only the suspect would know, and the Sheriff’s Office has confirmed they a...

Investigators just held a news conference on the latest information into Savanna Guthrie’s missing mom, and several moments jumped out to us. First, the sheriff was asked twice about whether a ransom has been asked surrounding the abduction of 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie, and both times the sheriff did NOT say no. Instead he said his team was following all of their investigative leads. The she...

Authorities are pleading with the public for help in finding 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie.  She was last seen late Saturday at her Arizona home.  After initially investigating the case as a "missing, vulnerable adult," the sheriff now says there is a crime scene at her home and he believes she was abducted.  He also said they haven't dismissed the theory that her disappearance is conne...

After nine hours of deliberating, the jury in the Brendan Banfield trial found Banfield guilty of all four charges, including two counts of aggravated murder for the deaths of his wife Christine and a stranger he lured to his home, Joe Ryan.  Banfield looked stunned as the verdict was read aloud.  The court quickly moved forward, scheduling his sentencing date for May, where the 40 year...