The Murder Diaries

From a shocking car crash to the haunting questions left behind, Paige and Natalie unpack Something’s Wrong with Aunt Diane, examining the theories, contradictions, and devastating impact on the families involved. They discuss how uncertainty, denial, and grief collide in one of the most unsettling true-crime documentaries. To join in on next week’s conversation, we’re watching Amy Bradley Is Miss...

In this special collaboration with Camp Chaos podcast, we dive into the chilling Rob Reiner murder case, unpacking the twists and turns of the investigation and the questions that still linger. Along the way, we explore other gripping true crime stories, blending sharp analysis from a pop culture lens and unfiltered conversation for a can’t-miss episode. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit meg...

Destiny McClain was a homebody whose entire world revolved around her family. But one night, she left home to hang out with some friends and was senselessly murdered. Today, her mother and sisters are still searching for answers about who shot and killed Destiny. If you or someone you know have information about Destiny McClain’s murder, her family asks that you please contact the Phoenix Police a...

From a devastating abduction to a powerful story of survival, Natalie and Paige discuss Kidnapped: Elizabeth Smart, Elizabeth’s newest Netflix documentary, and reflect on trauma, resilience, and reclaiming your voice. They unpack how her story has been told, and what it means to hear it directly from Elizabeth herself. If you’d like to join in on next week’s conversation, we’re watching Something’...

In this week’s Unscripted, we take a deep dive into the life, legendary career, and haunting final chapter of Natalie Wood. We also explore the lingering questions surrounding her tragic 1981 death off the coast of Catalina Island, a mystery that continues to captivate Hollywood and beyond. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

An unidentified set of remains found near a lake in Utah, dubbed Saltair Sally, sat unclaimed for eleven years, until a facial reconstruction photo crossed Nancie Bakoles’ computer screen. She knew it was her daughter, Niki, who’d disappeared after losing custody of her daughter. A DNA match confirmed Sally’s identity as 20-year-old Nikole Bakoles, but brought forward a surge of questions that nee...

This week, Natalie & Paige dive into Prime’s Glitter & Greed, unpacking the wild rise and messy unraveling of the Lisa Frank empire. They talk power, all things rainbow, and what really happens when a brand built on joy starts cracking behind the scenes. To join along for next week’s conversation, here’s your heads up to watch Kidnapped: Elizabeth Smart on Netflix. Learn more about your ad choices...

Paige & Natalie unpack Princess Diana’s rise, her complicated marriage, and the media frenzy that shaped her life. They explore how Diana rewrote the rules of royalty and why her legacy still resonates decades later. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

When he stepped outside his house one morning to head out for another day of work, Eric Nelams was shot to death on his carport next to his truck. Was this some random shooting, or were the culprits of a white-collar fraud conspiracy behind his murder? If you or someone you know have information about the murder of Eric Nelams, you can contact Alabama Crime Stoppers at 334-215-7867. You can also c...

Natalie and Paige break down HBO Max’s Bama Rush and the culture it tried to capture. From rushTok expectations to Greek life secrecy and what the documentary leaves out, Unscripted digs into the internet discourse and controversy. Next week we're discussing the Glitter & Greed documentary available on Prime. (Watch it and join in on the conversation.) Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megap...

Paige and Natalie break down Addison Rae’s meteoric rise, evolving career, and carefully crafted pop persona. From TikTok fame to music, movies, and major brand deals, this episode explores how this internet star crossed into mainstream pop culture. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

January 13th, 1999 started out like any other day for high school student Hae Min Lee. She got out of bed, ate her breakfast, and drove the short distance to Woodlawn High School. When Hae left her school campus that afternoon she was her usual upbeat and joyful self as she waved goodbye to friends and headed toward her car. It was the last time Hae would ever be seen alive. Listen Ad Free And Get...

This week on DocuFiles, the girls break down the Brandy Hellville documentary, unpacking the brand’s rise, the controversies, and the conversations it forces us to have about fashion and culture. Next week we're discussing the Bama Rush documentary available on HBO Max. (Consider this your heads up to watch and join in on the conversation.) Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adch...

Natalie and Paige break down Blake Lively’s career, public image, and how she became one of the most talked-about women in pop culture. From Hollywood sweetheart to discourse magnet, this episode explores the high and lows of Blake's life thus far. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

When 32-year-old Kimberly Avila didn’t return home after a night out in May of 2017, her family knew something was wrong. Kimberly was a woman of color and part of the LGBTQ+ community, living in a heavily religious Texas town, just on the border of Mexico. Rumors and accusations have circled the case, with no actual evidence, but Kimberly’s family remains unwavering in their search and in their b...

Introducing our new segment, DocuFiles, where we'll be discussing true crime and true crime adjacent documentaries every Tuesday. We'd love to chat with YOU about the docus; so, leave us a comment to let us know your thoughts on the documentary and what you'd like to chat about next! This week, Natalie & Paige unpack Quiet on Set, diving into the uncomfortable truths and conversations it sparked,...

This week on Unscripted, Paige & Natalie get into THE Hailey Bieber. Model, mogul, and internet’s most debated wife. The girls break down the timeline, the rumors, and everything in between. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

In November of 1984, Bibi Lee went missing while jogging in a northern California park. Her bludgeoned body was found in this same park one month later, and her boyfriend would eventually make startling statements to Oakland police. Did Bibi’s life end at his hands? Or was someone else responsible? Listen Ad Free And Get Access to Exclusive Journal Entries Episodes: Spotify: ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠...

This week on Unscripted, Natalie & Paige dive deep into Justin Bieber’s life and career. They discuss all the iconic highs, messy moments, and everything in between. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

14-year-old Danielle Bell was still a child when she fell in with a group of men who preyed on teenage girls. Within six months of meeting these men, she disappeared. Danielle still hasn’t been found. Danielle was last seen on September 28th, 2001 in Pensacola, Florida. She was reported to be wearing a sky-blue halter top with glitter in the fabric, a blue Tommy Hilfiger jacket, black pants, black...

This week on Unscripted, Natalie and Paige dive into Demi Lovato’s life and career. They unpack Demi's headline moments, career highs and lows, and everything in between. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Original Air Date: 6/15/23 Amber Rene Hagerman was born on November 25, 1986. In 1996 she was in the third grade and attended Berry Elementary School in Arlington, Texas. She loved the Disney princess Pocahontas, playing with Barbie dolls and teddy bears, and riding her bike. Amber was extremely close to her family, she adored her mother Donna and her younger brother Ricky. Hers is a story that le...

This week on Unscripted, Natalie and Paige dive into the wild ride that is Katy Perry’s career, from her church choir beginnings to becoming one of the biggest pop stars on the planet. They’re talking about the hits you couldn’t escape, the infamous Super Bowl sharks, and how Katy’s playful, over-the-top style changed what pop music looked like in the 2010s. Whether you’re a casual listener or sti...

Original Air Date: 8/13/2025 Every year, between one in every 1,000 to 2,000 babies is born deaf or hard of hearing. For about 90% of these children, they’re born into hearing families, families who suddenly begin a journey they never expected. Maxine and Raymond Raffle were one such family. Their daughter, Lonene “Lonnie” was diagnosed as deaf at 18 months old. From that moment forward, they walk...

This week on Unscripted, Natalie and Paige tackle Britain’s most photogenic power couple: Victoria and David Beckham. From Posh Spice to polished designer, from football legend to full-time icon, the duo break down how the Beckhams built an empire on coordinated outfits, impeccable branding, and a marriage that somehow survived the tabloids and four kids. Our Unscripted segment will be moving to i...