Gifted Underachievers

If people are born into a creative life, what is it that draws them to one art over another? If the fates had been different, what creative domain would a person choose? Pat and James both believe that they were slated to do something creative in their lives and discuss what that means. The talk widens to people who are stars in one creative field and very accomplished artists in another. Unfortun...

The United States of America is gearing up for one of their biggest retail frenzies of the year, aka Thanksgiving. But here in the Gifted Underachievers Clubhouse, we’re overlooking the troubled roots and current expression of this feast day and feeling gratitude for having gotten this far through the year. James takes a break from managing the culling of the turkeys while he and Pat discuss what...

Pat and James dive deep into perfectionism and how it limits the creative mind and creative capacity. The Gifted Underachievers then break perfectionism down into three types: * Those who never start because they are never ready. * Those who finish the work but never release it. * Those who release the work but let it languish from neglect. One possible answer: Think like a comedian who is willing...

Are you a chaotrope or kosmotrope? For most of his early life, James was an extreme chaotrope. At a young age, Pat carried a briefcase (obvious kosmotrope). And yet, James found the religion of defeating chaotic workflows while Pat turned out to be pretty damn cool…and exceptionally organized. In this segment, the Gifted Underachievers discuss identifying chaos in their respective work habits and...

The dynamic duo have learned that sometimes their creative eyes are much bigger than their creative capacities. This realization came about during a chat about the Gifted Underachievers merch store and how it may have been better to launch lean than try to fill out multiple categories. In essence, go from the exciting idyl to the satisfying achievement. How? * Be specific. * Know your capacity for...

We’re less than a month in to the contest experiment (that is, entering contests with our creative work as a way to potentially make money, get published, raise profile, etc.). In this segment, James astonishes Pat with his assertion that the experiment so far is “exciting,” even “Thrilling.” He describes his stringent research process for finding a good “fit” and weeding out scams. Pat, on the ot...

What’s your first instinct when you encounter a new opportunity? Do you tend to say yes, no, or “let me think about it?” Should we always say yes? If you’re interested but lack the capacity to go all in, how can you negotiate the terms of your engagement? The Gifted Underachievers discuss various ways to respond to a new creative opportunity, whether it’s an offer of a job, a project, or a collabo...

All is not well in the Gifted Underachiever Clubhouse as James threatens to yet again derail a segment with his spurious “science facts” and Pat draws a very heavy line: Stop it or Die. Will the GU odyssey end here? Or will harmony prevail? Questions for Listeners: * When’s the last time you had a work fight? * Who won: you or the enemy? * Do you like James’s “science facts?” Click “Leave a commen...

Special guest hosts Bart and Jimmy (if you are a literary agent: ignore any references to Pat and James) explore recent reporting by Jane Friedman that literary agents are feeling upset that acquisitions editors are taking too long to reply to submissions, if at all. In fact, some agents are proposing a mandatory three week turnaround time for submissions. Yep, the same people who tell writers tha...

Pat and James explore the sensation of being creatively ‘blocked’ or, perhaps more aptly, getting stuck creatively. Then the Gifted Underachievers press on with a deep dive into how to get unstuck…creatively. First, Pat and James describe being blocked as something that often happens in the moment, as the creative work is in progress but we are broken from our flow. It could be a sensation that th...

Unbelievably, John Irving has yet another book out (at 408 pages a novella for him) despite his stay at the Gifted Underachiever club house. Nevertheless, we drop in on Pat and James as they discuss their plans for preparing John Irving for the holidays. Question for Listeners: How many books does he have in him? For Further Exploration: John Irving on Obsessions Thanks for listening to Gifted Und...

For a full year, your Gifted Underachievers applied for grants to fund our creative projects. Were we good at it? Not really. Did we enjoy it? A hard no. Did we have any success? Sort of. Dobes did qualify for a grant, but the funding body ran out of money before they got to her name. In other words, they said yes to the project but no money changed hands. Our takeaway? It’s a tricky system to nav...

In this segment, Gifted Underachiever James Buchanan explains the concept of functional fixedness, talks about how it can impair our ability to produce meaningful creative work, and suggests a few solutions. Questions for Listeners: * Do you care if Mary Roach gets a blurb from Bill Bryson? * If yes, why? If not, why not? * What’s your own way of overcoming functional fixedness? For Further Explor...

In this segment, Gifted Underachiever Dobes christens the actions of the devilish duo—evil twins, if you will—that can hold back the creation of a work-in-progress “the Hard-Easy Effect.” One evil twin is Procrastination—specifically, the kind of procrastination born from the mistaken idea that there’s not enough time to do any meaningful work on the project today because it will be hard to get in...

Pat provides a very solid 7-part marketing starter kit for creatives to continuously market ourselves and our works. The pieces are: * Understanding Budget & ROI. * Road Testing. * Network & Community. * Get Uncomfortable. * Minimum Viable Product * Observe, Analyze & Pivot. * Identify & Connect with Audience. The intent is to understand these seven elements, employ them, then as you learn, feed w...

One thing that can get in the way of creativity is that we can rationalize about our failures and thus never improve. Maybe we think “what I’ve done is good enough, and better than most.” When the rejection comes, you make it about the problems around the sale or with the gatekeeper, rather than the quality of your art. Or the opposite might be true. Maybe your art IS good but you can’t recognize...

Proving that silliness can trample any topic, Pat and James fall apart while discussing farmers’ markets…so much so that Pat’s mic cannot pick up her laughter. Lots of silly fun and then a nice memory shared by Pat. Question for Listeners: * What is your strangest farmers’ or flea market find? For Further Exploration (And Just for Fun): Business Time: Flight of the Conchords Thanks for listening t...

While working on a project, James is reading stories by well-known authors to see how they’ve handled similar topics—a bit of exploration to find inspiration. The Gifted Underachievers wonder: is this wise? Is it valid, or is it too close to stealing? What are the risks? When balanced against the rewards, are they worth it? How do we find inspiration and new ideas anyway? We go to prolific creativ...

In the act of sending out a short story to yet more literary journals. Gifted Underachiever James is hit by the thought, “Why bother?” Is this the first sign of a burgeoning nihilism? Sort of, but not really. In fact, it is James feeling like literary magazines are becoming a pointless exercise. He’s met mostly by rejection, often from young people at a college MFA program. But even when the hoped...

Here in the Gifted Underachiever clubhouse, we rarely disagree. But if we were to engage in conflict, James knows how to get out of it. He has come across a resource advising the use of 7 simple phrases to help one regain control of a conversation—specifically, a conversation with a creative client or collaborator on a particular project. Hope you enjoy this spirited discussion of why these 7 phra...

Under the category of “overcoming self-doubt and imposter syndrome,” James suggests that the Gifted Underachievers start a “kindness file,” aka an “artistic wins journal.” He and Pat discuss whether this idea has merit, propose some names and formats for the concept that aren’t quite so douchey, and decide that yes, it just might be worth trying. Questions for Listeners: * Do you have a box, journ...

Pat and James display key BBC mystery expertise when discussing Miss Marple, Hercule Poirot, Scottish criminal law, and a few more embarrassing (and humorous) thoughts on Death by Misadventure. Question for Listeners: * Who is your favorite: Poirot or Marple? Perhaps Vera? Thanks for listening to Gifted Underachievers! This post is public so feel free to share it. If you’re not already a subscribe...

There’s more than one type of nostalgia around art. Art media coverage seems to highlight the Old Masters, people who haven’t made art in a long time—heck, they haven’t even breathed in centuries! Their work gets a disproportionate amount of arts coverage not because art critics are nostalgic for an earlier time, and not because their art is awesome (although it is), but because of the giant sums...

Right now, Pat sees creative work as often being underappreciated (unless it sells well). She encounters many creatives who are struggling to find an audience, produce consistently, and make a living with their art. She’d like to see more accessible local community-building spaces and support for artists, both public and individual. She’d like to see easier and more transparent access to studio sp...

There’s really not much to say other than Pat and James get very giggly while talking about boxes, Pat’s potential transformation during her upcoming trip to Europe, and the fun of being a misanthrope. Questions for Listeners Nope. Not going down that road! For Further Exploration Nobody should be exploring these boxes. Thanks for listening to Gifted Underachievers! This post is public so feel fre...