The Paranormal Divide

In this episode, SherRee reads a chilling collection of true Reddit Hat Man stories—featuring encounters that go far beyond a single sighting. One long, deeply unsettling story follows a Hat Man seemingly stalking a child’s bedroom, with other members of the family experiencing strange and unexplainable activity at the same time. Another story comes from someone who believes they’ve cracked the co...

In this episode, Alana dives into the haunting case of Elizabeth Short—better known as the victim in the infamous Black Dahlia murder. In 1947, Elizabeth Short was found brutally murdered in Los Angeles, her case quickly becoming one of the most shocking and widely publicized unsolved crimes in American history. Dubbed the “Black Dahlia” by the press, her story is filled with mystery, media frenzy...

In this episode, Alana reads a collection of true Reddit alien encounter stories that are as unsettling as they are unexplained. A man comes face to face with something outside his window—a figure with a completely indescribable face. A group of friends encounter a 7-foot shadowy being that refuses to react no matter what they do. And a college student wakes up to see a creature leaning over his s...

In this episode, SherRee dives into the unsettling case of Elisa Lam—a mystery that continues to haunt the internet and true crime community. Before her disappearance, Elisa’s past revealed struggles and strange online activity that some believe may hold clues. Then came the now-infamous elevator footage, showing her behaving in a way that sparked countless theories—from paranoia to something far...

In this episode, SherRee reads a collection of true Reddit stories about creepy things kids have said—and some of them are impossible to explain. A child insists they were once their mother’s father in India. Another sees their brother blue and floating in the bathtub. One little boy is continuously visited by a “brown man” outside making faces at him, while another claims he can see a man standin...

In this episode, Alana dives into the chilling history of the Hinterkaifeck murders, one of the most disturbing unsolved cases in true crime. In 1922, an entire family was brutally murdered on a remote farm in Bavaria — but the nightmare didn’t end there. Strange footprints in the snow, unexplained noises in the attic, and evidence that someone may have been living in the house before the murders...

Tonight’s episode features a collection of true Reddit scary stories that range from deeply unsettling to downright terrifying. A haunting encounter may be tied to a mysterious lifelong illness, a girl believes she was driven from her bedroom by her grandfather’s ghost, and in a Victorian mansion, a room’s door refuses to stay closed no matter what the family does. These — and several more real pa...

In this episode, we dive deep into the tragedy of the RMS Titanic — not just how it sank, but the chilling mysteries that still surround it more than a century later. We break down the history of the “unsinkable” ship, the eerie weather conditions the night it struck the iceberg, and the chain reaction of human errors and overlooked warnings that led to disaster. From coal fires and brittle rivets...

In this episode, we dive into some of Reddit’s creepiest true stories involving pets… and the things they might be seeing that we can’t. From a dog that wakes up every single night at 3AM… to a dream about shadow figures that felt far too real… to cats that seem to guard their owners from something lurking in their room… we’re unpacking the chilling moments where animals react before humans even k...

In November 2022, four University of Idaho students were found murdered in their off-campus home in Moscow, Idaho — while two of their roommates were left alive in the same house. In this episode, Alana takes a deep dive into the timeline of events surrounding the killings of Kaylee Goncalves, Madison Mogen, Xana Kernodle, and Ethan Chapin. From the early hours of that devastating morning to the i...

Listener discretion advised… because this one gets weird. In this episode, we’re diving into both listener submitted and Reddit horror stories that had us side-eyeing the woods, checking behind us at night, and reconsidering every rental agreement we’ve ever signed. First: something in the forest brutally mutilates a deer… but the real question is what was watching from the tree line. Then, a late...

Bloody Mary. Light as a Feather. Scratch Back. The Sandman. In this episode, SherRee explores the dark history behind the creepy children’s games many of us played growing up — and why so many of them are connected to spirits, summoning rituals, and urban legends. From staring into mirrors to calling on the Bloody Mary spirit, to the eerie levitation game Light as a Feather, Stiff as a Board , to...

In this episode, Alana dives into the paranormal side of the Lizzie Borden case. Discover the chilling ghost sightings reported at both the Lizzie Borden House and her 14-bedroom mansion, Maplecroft. Hear about creepy EVPs, eerie sounds, and spine-tingling encounters in this thrilling Part 2!

Over a century later, the name Lizzie Borden still sends a chill down the spine. In 1892, Andrew and Abby Borden were brutally murdered with an axe in their Fall River, Massachusetts home. Their daughter, Lizzie, quickly became the prime suspect — tried in court, scrutinized by the press, and immortalized by one of the most famous crime rhymes in history. But was Lizzie truly a cold-blooded killer...

This episode features listener submitted stories paranormal encounters that escalate from unsettling to outright terrifying. A full body apparition of a little girl in Scotland. A man is seen after breaking into a house. A woman is violently dragged down a hallway by something unseen. A child describes a man with no arms, his face smeared with what appears to be "spaghetti sauce" laughing at her....

In this episode, Alana takes us inside one of the most haunted landmarks in America — the St. Augustine Lighthouse . Towering over Florida’s oldest city, this historic lighthouse is infamous for chilling encounters: unexplained footsteps spiraling up the stairs, shadow figures watching from the top, eerie voices carried on the wind, and the playful yet unsettling presence of the ghostly children s...

In this episode, SherRee and Alana are joined by a very special guest—SherRee's sister Reann—who returns to answer lingering questions about the chilling listener story she previously wrote in. But that’s only the beginning. Together, they dive into brand-new true paranormal experiences, including a terrifying encounter with a Woman in White who chased her?? Was it a spirit, a warning, or some...

SherRee explores the both terrifying and hilarious case that is Gef the Talking Mongoose: In the early 1930s, a quiet farmhouse on the Isle of Man became the center of one of the strangest paranormal cases in history. A family claimed they were sharing their home with a foul-mouthed, joke-cracking, talking mongoose named Gef. Was Gef a mischievous cryptid? A poltergeist with a personality? A case...

Alana brings us two terrifying Reddit stories guaranteed to give you nightmares. We dive into the chilling tale of the "Bloody Man," a figure who relentlessly terrorizes not just the writer. Then, we uncover a family's horrifying fear of what lurks in the forest behind their home. These stories prove some things are better left unread....at least after dark. Music: Illuminati Swagger...

SherRee takes a deep dive into the chilling real-world events that inspired Wes Craven’s iconic film A Nightmare on Elm Street. The true story behind the movie is far darker—and far more unsettling—than anything shown on screen. Follow so you don’t miss upcoming episodes and more strange, true tales from the shadows! Music: Illuminati Swagger by: Albert Behar

After the thrilling mystery and true-crime deep dive of Part 1, Alana returns to Villisca to explore the haunted happenings inside this small-town horror home. From disembodied voices to full-body apparitions—and even a mysterious stabbing reported during a ghost-hunting investigation—this episode uncovers the chilling paranormal legacy tied to the Villisca Axe Murder House. Join us for this eerie...

SherRee shares the true crime and terrible tragedy of the Villisca, Iowa axe murders — eight poor souls viciously taken on the night of June 10th, 1912. Join us for Part One of Two as we walk through the gruesome details and explore multiple theories about what happened on that fateful night. Be sure to give us your theories in the comments, we would love to read them and give us a follow if you h...

SherRee and Alana dive deep into the eerie history and lore surrounding sleep paralysis after reading a chilling listener submission recounting their mysterious experiences. The duo also shares their own terrifying encounters, sparking lively debates, spine-tingling stories, and plenty of movie talk along the way. Buckle up for a roller coaster of frights, laughs, and late-night chills in this unf...

Alana and SherRee dive into another chilling Iowa haunt — the infamous Edinburgh Manor , just outside of Monticello, Iowa. This dilapidated building is said to be teeming with restless spirits… and maybe even something darker. From the laughter of a mysterious little girl to the unsettling presence known only as the Joker , this investigation will keep you on edge from start to finish. Are you bra...

Alana and SherRee dive into their very first listener-submitted story, sent in by SherRee’s sister, Reann. Reann shares a chilling experience involving a "peek-a-boo" ghost that haunted and terrified her children. Was it just a trick of the eyes, or is something more sinister at play? Join us as we explore this eerie encounter! Don’t forget to give us a follow and send in your own creepy...