The Dispatch
Advisory Opinions
Advisory Opinions is a legal podcast by The Dispatch. Hosts David French and Sarah Isgur meet twice a week to talk about the law, the courts, their collision with politics, and why it all matters.
Určitě navštivte web podcastu a podpořte jeho tvůrce: advisoryopinions.thedispatch.com
Autor
The Dispatch
Kategorie
Web podcastu
Nejnovější epizoda
19. lis 2026
Kde poslouchat?
Podcasty v aplikaci Replaio Radio Už brzyPodcasty míří do aplikace už brzy. Nainstaluj si ji teď a jako první uvidíš úplně nový pohled na podcasty
Epizody
Prosecuting the Parent of a School Shooter 10.09.2024 1:10:35
Sarah and David discuss the recent school shooting in Georgia, which is raising questions about parental responsibility and the limits of legal liability. The Agenda: —Georgia school shooting —6th Circuit punts campaign finance question to Supreme Court —Body cam footage hasn't done everything we wanted it to —Debating the scope of the Second Amendment Show Notes: —Buckley v. Valeo —McConnell v. F...
Free Speech vs. the Algorithm 05.09.2024 1:04:55
Sarah details life under a wicked curse and David defends his position in The Dispatch's fantasy football league. Oh, and today's legal theme for the podcast is the First Amendment. The Agenda: —Role of public defenders —Criminal justice reform —Horrific TikTok algorithms and Section 230 —Gray areas of Section 230 —The back and forth with Sarah Palin's defamation case —Should the dues from the Ore...
Unity Is Dead, Long Live the Union 29.08.2024 1:18:56
Sarah and David break down the latest update in Jack Smith’s January 6 case against Donald Trump before speaking with Yuval Levin about his book, American Covenant: How the Constitution Unified Our Nation―and Could Again. The Agenda: —Jack Smith’s superseding indictment —Not thinking alike but acting together —Federalist No. 10 —Underestimating how unified we are —Proceduralism is not amoral —Rest...
A Christian Case for Criminal Justice Reform 27.08.2024 1:14:02
Sarah and David catch up on the latest case in Second Amendment jurisprudence before talking with Matt Martens about his new book, Reforming Criminal Justice: A Christian Proposal. \The Agenda: —Matt’s faith —The prosecutor-to-defense-attorney pipeline —The plea bargaining system —The issues with eye-witness testimony —Brady violations —Should prosecutors have absolute immunity? —Racial discrimina...
Fixing the Supreme Court 22.08.2024 1:04:55
David Lat joins Sarah and David to break down recent Supreme Court trends and discuss Lat’s legal fiction novel, Supreme Ambitions. The Agenda: —Is the shadow docket problem solved? —Supreme Court approval rating —Stabilizing the Supreme Court —Lat’s pick for most interesting justice —Who will win the text, history, and tradition fight? —Advice for law students —Lat’s book, Supreme Ambitions —Stra...
Would You Like a Musket to Go With Your Latte? 20.08.2024 1:11:36
Writing with quill pens, quartering Secret Service agents, and shooting 18th-century guns. A.J. Jacobs joins Sarah and David to discuss his book, It's All Relative: Adventures Up and Down the World's Family, and his experience living by the Constitution. But first, this podcast can’t escape a little bit of legal news, including a shocking decision by the Supreme Court. The Agenda: —SCOTUS blocks B...
Bob Bauer Still Thinks Robert Hur Was Wrong 15.08.2024 1:32:23
Former White House counsel Bob Bauer joins Sarah Isgur and David French to talk about his new book, The Unraveling: Reflections on Politics Without Ethics and Democracy in Crisis. They also discuss the role of a presidential attorney, whether Special Counsel Robert Hur crossed a line by reporting on President Joe Biden's cognitive decline, and what it was like to prep the president for his fateful...
How to Disagree 13.08.2024 1:31:19
In this three-guest special episode (wait, does David count as one? Are we still doing that?), Noah Phillips, former Federal Trade Commission commissioner and co-chair of the antitrust practice at Cravath, joins Sarah and David to discuss the reality of antitrust law. Then, John Inazu, the Sally D. Danforth Distinguished Professor of Law and Religion at Washington University in St. Louis, joins to...
Thoughts and Feelings on Maryland’s Assault Rifle Ban 08.08.2024 56:42
Our August-themed legal book discussion is postponed for one episode, but don’t fret: There’s more than enough legal news to fill a show, thanks to gun rights and antitrust cases. The Agenda: —Maryland’s assault weapons ban is constitutional —Text, history, and tradition as … rational basis review? Or something. —Original jurisdiction and Missouri’s attempt to put forth a stupid case —Is Google th...
Should Academic Freedom Be a Constitutional Right? 06.08.2024 1:19:01
Sarah and David kick off the Advisory Opinions August book series and invite Professor Keith Whittington on the pod to discuss his new book You Can't Teach That!: The Battle over University Classrooms. But first the two dig into David’s conversation with Justice Neil Gorsuch. The Agenda: —Justice Gorsuch: Go to law school. —Defining originalism —The Supreme Court children’s book —The history of ac...
If You Really Want Judicial Ethics Reform… 01.08.2024 1:10:40
Justice Kagan makes remarks to the 9th Circuit and President Biden proposes SCOTUS reforms. The usual slow-moving summer legal news drag is disrupted by a number interesting cases and eye-raising comments. On the docket: —To stand or not to stand at a desk —Justice Kagan says Supreme Court reforms are "fair" —The Supreme Court’s caseload —Are justices friendly? —President Biden’s proposed reforms...
Progressivism and Eugenics in the Court of Justice Holmes 30.07.2024 1:05:02
Sarah and David welcome special guest Anthony Sanders, director of the Center for Judicial Engagement at the Institute for Justice, to eviscerate Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr. Plus: David’s rant on Presumed Innocent. The Agenda: —Judicial engagement —Social Darwinism and “putting to death the inadequate” —Progressive forgiveness for progressives —First Amendment —Civil rights and judicial abdi...
Can Kamala Take the Money … Legally? 25.07.2024 56:47
Sarah and David are joined by Notre Dame law professor Derek Muller, who teaches “Presidential Nominations in a Time of Uncertainty,” to discuss the legality of swapping out (presumptive) party nominees, the potential consequences of doing so, and the complexity of state election laws at-large. The Agenda: —Can Kamala Harris inherit Joe Biden’s PAC money? —Will Republicans successfully keep Kamala...
Lobotomizing the DOJ 18.07.2024 1:12:06
Sarah and David answer listener emails, covering everything from judicial federalism, to the Supreme Court’s upcoming tech term, to potential SCOTUS reforms. The Agenda: —Constitutionality of the special counsel —The Nixon precedent —Independent judgment of lower courts —Predictability and the rule of law —The Texas pornography case: children’s rights or adult’s rights? —Injunctions as extraordina...
INDICTMENT WATCH: Judge Cannon's Bonkers-Adjacent Decision to Dismiss Trump's Case 16.07.2024 39:08
Judge Aileen Cannon dismissed on Monday the charges brought by special counsel Jack Smith against former President Donald Trump for mishandling classified documents. So, um, what just happened? Sarah Isgur and special guest David French discuss. The Agenda: -Why Judge Cannon thinks Jack Smith's position is illegal. -Rating the decision, from solid law to bonkerstown. -What will the DOJ do now? -Tr...
The Assassination Attempt 15.07.2024 1:01:18
Sarah, Steve, Jonah, and David French discuss the assassination attempt against former President Donald Trump during a Pennsylvania rally over the weekend. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
‘Who Has the Pen?’ 12.07.2024 1:13:16
Could Joe Biden sue a faithless delegate? Would Brown v. Board exist if a supermajority had opposed integration? Is the next generation of lawyers doomed? In a special live recording at the American Enterprise Institute, Sarah and David contemplate a series of worst-case hypotheticals and answer audience questions. Bonus: originalist David French (somewhat) defends the Warren Court. Agenda: —Bound...
Is ‘Text, History, and Tradition’ Alive and Well? 09.07.2024 1:28:40
Kannon Shanmugam and his summer associates return to Advisory Opinions to look back on the SCOTUS term and discuss the state of “text, history, and tradition.” The Agenda: —Big themes from this SCOTUS term —Was this the administrative law term? —Should we stop thinking about SCOTUS “terms”? —The health of the First Amendment —“The media now owns Amy Coney Barrett” —Justice Thomas’ dissent in Rahim...
Winning Without Winning 04.07.2024 1:55:55
On today’s super-mega-extravagant episode, Sarah and David celebrate America’s birthday by gifting everyone a magnificently long podcast. First on the docket: more analysis of the SCOTUS immunity decision. The Agenda: —Facial challenges in Moody v. NetChoice —Welcome, Father of the Pod —Should prosecutors be totally immune? —No more bad science! —Ongoing debate over Section 230 —Romney: Corporatio...
Trump Is ‘Absolutely Immune’ ... Kind Of 01.07.2024 1:04:40
Sarah and David break down the Supreme Court decision in Trump v. United States. The Agenda: —Unanimous decision on Moody v. NetChoice —SCOTUS stat pack —Three buckets of immunity —Immunity takeaways: yes, no, and maybe —Presidential immunity and accountability —The role of the electorate in holding presidents accountable —Does the Constitution prevent despots and tyrants? Show Notes: —David's NYT...
Chevron Is Dead, Long Live Chevron 28.06.2024 1:20:26
We're not talking about Trump and Biden, but we are discussing something that could make double-hater voters less worried about the future of presidents and executive power: the final stake through the Chevron doctrine. The Agenda: —Chevron is overruled —Jarkesy decision —How "old think" plays out in the two above decisions —Sarah's offended by Sotomayor —The non-Trump January 6 case —Are homeless...
Supreme Court: We’re Not Santa Claus 27.06.2024 1:29:57
Sarah and David return for a truly prolific episode covering another SCOTUS decision day and revisit where they stand on originalism and its faults. The Agenda: —Doctrine coded vs. culture-war coded —Did the government coerce social media companies in 2020? —David, you ignorant slut —Interpreting “corruptly” —The accidental release of Idaho abortion case —Is SCOTUS strategic in its opinion release...
Justice Stephen Breyer: Law Is Not a Science 25.06.2024 1:24:22
In a special live recording from San Francisco in late May, Sarah interviewed former Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer about his judicial philosophy, the future of the court, and accepting dissent in America. The Agenda: — How snails explain the Supreme Court — To recuse or to not recuse? — The Court’s public approval and its response to public approval — Rule of law — Unenumerated rights — Hum...
Rahimi Is Here and It Is Glorious 22.06.2024 1:12:03
The Supreme Court has decided 8-1 in favor of the government in United States v. Rahimi. Sarah and David break down the decision before getting to a few sleeper cases from the day. The Agenda: —“Y’all misunderstood Bruen” —History is instructive, not binding —18th-century policy vs. 21st-century problems —The future of gun control —“Bad man stays in jail” doctrine —Trump’s SCOTUS nominees in a sec...
Squirrely Religious Expression 20.06.2024 1:03:25
Awaiting a week full of emergency pods, Sarah and David discuss latest round of SCOTUS opinions and take a look at a religious expression case. The Agenda: —Your foreign earnings are taxable —Malicious prosecutions, do they fall under the charge-specific rule or any-crime rule? —The Fifth Circuit was wrong —Defining expert testimony —Louisiana's Ten Commandment's law Show Notes: —Georgia Tech sued...
Podobné podcasty
Replaio není vydavatelem podcastů; názvy pořadů, obálky a audio patří jejich autorům a šíří se přes veřejné RSS kanály